Death of three cadets in an avalanche in the Alps: the prosecutor's office demands a sentence for the instructor
Prosecutors in the Italian town of Aosta are seeking a four-month prison sentence for a mountain guide Matteo Giglio on charges of manslaughter. The 53-year-old instructor was the sole survivor of an avalanche at an altitude of more than 3,000 meters near colle della Tsanteleina, near the French border.
The tragedy occurred on April 13, 2023, during a practical training course for future alpine guides. The disaster claimed the lives of a 38-year-old ski mountaineering champion Lorenzo Holzknecht, a 43-year-old ski instructor Sandro Dublanc, and a 36-year-old mountain rescue worker Elia Meta.
The prosecution emphasizes that the avalanche danger level that day was estimated at three points, but the group leader did not calculate the risks accurately and did not organize a sequential descent along the dangerous couloir. According to the investigation, passing the section one by one could minimize the number of victims.
Matteo Giglio himself denies the charges and says he did everything he could to save people. According to him, the snowboard broke off when one of the cadets crossed a layer of wind-blown snow that the rest of the group was avoiding. The relatives of the victims withdrew their civil lawsuits after the compensation was paid, and the final defense arguments in court are scheduled for December.
Context
To reconstruct in detail the climbers' movement along the dangerous slope, experts and investigators relied on GPS recordings from the group members' phones and smartwatches.
During the investigation, experts also drew attention to the lack of avalanche backpacks with airbags among the cadets, although the presence of such systems on ski touring routes is not legally mandatory.